Mathews Crossing sold for $49.5 million

A Texas-based apartment investor bought the Mathews Crossing Apartment Homes complex along Atlantic Boulevard last week for $49.5 million.

The new owner of Mathews Crossing is planning $12 million in renovations and upgrades to the apartment complex.
The new owner of Mathews Crossing is planning $12 million in renovations and upgrades to the apartment complex.
  • Columnists
  • Mathis Report
  • Share

Addison, Texas-based S2 Capital LLC, through SP Matthews LP, bought the complex in two deeds from ownership groups led by New York investor Pinchos Shemano.

Co-founder and Managing Partner Scott Everett said that at 1,103 units, Mathews Crossing, not far from Regency Square Mall in Arlington, is the largest apartment complex in the area.

He said it will be renamed soon and updated with $12 million in exterior and interior renovations.

Mathews Crossing, at 400 Century Drive and 401 Century Drive E., was built in 1972 and 1973.

Everett said the group also intends to buy the 458-unit Casa del Rio apartments near Jacksonville University in August and invest $5 million in renovations. It was built in 1973 and 1975, property records show.

That complex is at 3500 University Blvd. N.

S2 Capital will buy that from the same seller, he said. The seller bought it about a year ago. Everett did not divulge a purchase price.

Everett said the condition and security of the Mathews Crossing apartments are an issue and “something we will address.”

“We’ve done almost 30 acquisitions. This is all we do, every day, and it is what we look for,” he said.

Everett said S2 Capital likes in invest in “mismanaged, neglected properties.”

He indicated it was a successful strategy. “We are so far 30 for 30,” he said.

He and Harold “Skip” Bird founded the company in 2012 to build a multifamily “value-add” investment platform in the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

Its website says it seeks out underperforming or distressed “B,” “C” and “D” multifamily properties.

Its strategy is to make “cost-effective improvements” to provide tenants with “the best apartment, service, and living experience within the submarket.”

Everett said Mathews Crossing is its first deal in Florida. “We’ve got our feelers in the market. We will digest what we have there and in the next six months see how everything plays out.”

Mathews Crossing comprises about 110 buildings on 57 acres, he said.

The renovation estimate works out to almost $10,800 per unit, although the actual cost per apartment is less because the exterior upgrades are part of the overall investment.

Among the upgrades, Everett said there will be a new leasing office, new exterior siding and trim work, a new gym and upgraded pools.

The apartments will receive new appliances, flooring, painting, backsplash, showers and similar upgrades, he said.

“We will try to lock it down, clean it up and make it a good clean, safe, living option,” he said.

Rents will rise over five years from an average $600 a month now to about $800, he said.

Leasing rates vary, with the lowest for the studio efficiencies of about 400 square feet to the highest for the large three-bedroom units of about 1,170 square feet.

“We’ve been looking to buy in Jacksonville and in the Orlando and Tampa areas for a while and we had an opportunity,” Everett said.

He said S2 Capital bought the Mathews Crossing property from the same owner who sold property to him in Dallas.

The Mathews Crossing and Casa del Rio acquisitions are a healthy starting point. “That gives us pretty good scale in Jacksonville,” he said.

Benefit Street Partners Realty Operating Partnership L.P. of New York issued an almost $50.4 million mortgage to SP Matthews.

The deal was completed June 28 and recorded Monday with the Duval County Clerk of Court.



Special Offer: $5 for 2 Months!

Your free article limit has been reached this month.
Subscribe now for unlimited digital access to our award-winning business news.